Pakistanis give up on bid for ‘better life’ in Europe after boat tragedies

1690368600 Pakistanis give up on bid for better life in Europe
In this picture taken on July 18, 2023, Pakistani worker Muhammad Naeem Butt sits with his children at his home in Khuiratta. — AFP
On this image taken on July 18, 2023, Pakistani employee Muhammad Naeem Butt sits together with his kids at his house in Khuiratta. — AFP

KHUIRATTA, PAKISTAN: A resident of Khuiratta, a city in Kashmir, Muhammad Naeem Butt turned again to his nation after spending weeks in Libya making an attempt to succeed in Europe illegally, burying his hopes of constructing a greater life in Europe.

Butt deserted the journey after realizing it had already value a whole bunch of Pakistani lives this summer season.

Shovelling sand onto a truck surrounded by the luxurious valley, he says he ended his treacherous bid for a greater life when an overloaded fishing trawler sank off the coast of Greece final month.

As much as 350 Pakistanis had been believed to be among the many 600 who drowned, together with 24 from Butt’s hometown of Khuiratta.

“Trying again, I realise that the chance I took was not price it,” he advised AFP.

Butt is one in all a number of males from Khuiratta who advised AFP the catastrophe prompted them to surrender on the journey after reaching Libya.

“Life is outlined by the standard time you spend together with your kids and partner, not the sum of money you possess,” he mentioned.

In this picture taken on July 18, 2023, Pakistani worker Muhammad Naeem Butt sits with his children at his home in Khuiratta. — AFP
On this image taken on July 18, 2023, Pakistani employee Muhammad Naeem Butt sits together with his kids at his house in Khuiratta. — AFP

Tens of hundreds of younger males have handed over household fortunes to brokers who smuggle them to Europe, from the place remittances — much more priceless since Pakistan’s financial system slumped into disaster final yr — might be wired house.

Butt sought assist from family and friends, and his spouse bought her valuable wedding ceremony jewelry to scrape up the Rs2.2 million (round $7,500) he wanted to pay the human traffickers organising the journeys.

The primary legs of his journey had been uneventful — business flights to Dubai and Egypt, then overland to Libya, the place his ordeal actually began.

He spent two months in a makeshift shanty camp with 600 different migrants, ready for the day they’d be placed on a cargo ship to make the journey throughout the Mediterranean.

The anguish of households

As a substitute, they had been crowded onto a rickety fishing boat and spent eight days floundering in worldwide waters, the place they had been first fired on, then rammed, by a Libyan naval vessel, Butt mentioned.

They solely stayed afloat as a result of the navy ship deserted them when a storm struck, he added — but it surely returned days later to tow them again to port, the place they had been thrown in jail.

“They gave us the minimal quantity of meals to maintain us alive… a plate of macaroni or boiled rice could be shared amongst 5 folks,” Butt mentioned.

“They had been brutal folks.”

Whereas he was in jail, information reached his hometown of the migrant boat sinking off Greece, inflicting heartbreak and misery.

“I can not clarify the ache and anguish I went by means of for every week,” Butt’s spouse, Mehwish Matloob, advised AFP.

“I felt as if my whole world had crumbled earlier than me,” the 31-year-old mentioned, clutching a scarf.

In this picture taken on July 18, 2023, Muhammad Naeem Butt, who gave up on a perilous attempt to reach Europe, is kissed by his mother Razia Latif at their home in Pakistan. — AFP
On this image taken on July 18, 2023, Muhammad Naeem Butt, who gave up on a dangerous try to succeed in Europe, is kissed by his mom Razia Latif at their house in Pakistan. — AFP

Butt lastly bought out of jail and was in a position to contact his household to inform them he was alive.

His mom, 76-year-old Razia Latif, says she now regrets the hazard he endured.

“We thought that others had been making it to Europe, so why not ship him,” she mentioned.

“We’d have most popular begging had we recognized it was that tough.”

‘Greed’ and danger

The Worldwide Organisation for Migration has declared the Mediterranean passage the world’s most perilous migration route.

Round 1,728 migrants have gone lacking there this yr alone — surpassing the 1,417 disappearances recorded in 2022.

However households that do get a number of of their younger males overseas can prosper from the cash despatched again.

The noticeable disparity between households with family members in Europe and people with out is inflicting envy, mentioned Zafar Iqbal Ghazi of Kashmir’s Human Rights Discussion board group.

“If somebody has a single-storey house, proper subsequent to it you will discover a three-storey house, and greater mansions, and so forth,” he mentioned.

And the promise of untold riches overseas attracts these even nicely off by native requirements.

Hamza Bhatti was incomes Rs200,000 a month (round $700) as a driver in Saudi Arabia — sufficient to comfortably assist his spouse and their eight-month-old son — however he nonetheless noticed greener pastures in Europe.

“I believed that life in Europe could be extra vibrant and vibrant in comparison with my expertise in Saudi Arabia,” the 29-year-old advised AFP.

Bhatti was jailed after his boat was returned to port by Libyan authorities, and he discovered himself alongside Butt as information of the sinking broke.

“It was my greed that took me to the brink of demise,” he mentioned.

Smuggling brokers arrested

Ghazi mentioned greater than 175 children from Khuiratta alone left illegally for Europe final yr, and he believes any latest pause after the boat incident in Greece will solely be short-term.

Federal Investigation Company (FIA) mentioned 69 smuggling brokers had been arrested since a crackdown was launched final month, however prosecutions shall be tough.

“The problem lies in the truth that most of those children possess legitimate visas for Dubai, which they use as a place to begin to succeed in Libya,” one FIA official mentioned, talking anonymously to AFP.

“This isn’t a brand new phenomenon, and it’ll not finish after the Greece boat tragedy.”

European Union lawmakers have urged Brussels to supply assist to member states to strengthen their capability to hold out sea rescues, however attitudes in the direction of migrants are hardening throughout Europe, with Greece steadily slashing advantages for asylum seekers.

Mehwish says her husband Butt won’t ever once more try the journey — though traffickers refunded a part of his cost within the hope they would not be reported.

“I do not remorse shedding the gold, and I’m content material to reside in poverty so long as he’s with me,” she mentioned.